 Lean and mean: Ryan Doyle’s Sacrifice |
I confess I didn't watch all of the live-action films on the site, so I may well have missed some gems – and I'd be very pleased to hear if that's the case. The ones I did watch were a very mixed bag. Screentest winner Sacrifice directed by Ryan Doyle (Liverpool Hope University), is undoubtedly one of the silliest action films ever made. But, technically, it’s just extraordinary. Doyle sets out to do the full Hollywood Matrix / Steven Seagal guns and martial arts action sequence, and pulls it off! The script is awful and the acting is dire, but I suspect it won't matter too much for Doyle's career chances. The film is hugely ambitious, and lots of fun.
Which is more than you can say for some of the offerings in the archive. Given the incredible opportunity to make a film, some of these film makers have gone no further than the union bar for their locations and characters. Woeful, pusillanimous stuff – student film makers should be banned from campus! There’s a world out there, and it's full of stories, so get out and film it! Enough.
One person who has done just that is Aaron Sayers, from University of Portsmouth. His documentary A Way of Life follows the life of a violent Portsmouth football fan in the days leading up to a match with their traditional rivals Southampton (the "Scummers"). A good subject, told with strong interview material. Sayers makes a terrible decision, however, to stage a mock fight, which is then filmed as if it were authentic. A dangerous blurring of fact and fiction, which robs the film of its deserved power and veracity.
UK Student Films is a young site, so it will be exciting to watch the general standard of its offerings improve over time – to match the truly exceptional material it has already. If they are able to exclude some weaker films, so much the better.
To finish, here is something really special, showcased on the exposures film festival website. We will feature this year's festival (taking place from 23 to 27 November) later in the year. But for now, check out Just Waiting from 2006, for student film drama at its boldest and best. Awesome.
TM Satterthwaite |